Persil vs. Tide vs. Gain vs. Arm & Hammer

The four best-known detergent brands in the US cover the whole range: two premium cleaners (Tide and Persil), a scent-first mid-price brand (Gain) and a budget favorite (Arm & Hammer). Here is how they differ and how to choose.

Some links on this page are Amazon affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, LaundryArchive earns from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. Prices and pack sizes change, so check the current listing.

The short answer

  • Best cleaning: Tide or Persil. Both are premium; pick whichever is cheaper per load where you shop.
  • Best scent: Gain, if you like strong, long-lasting fragrance.
  • Best budget: Arm & Hammer, for everyday loads without heavy stains.
  • Sensitive skin: none of the scented versions. See free-and-clear detergents.

Side by side

TidePersilGainArm & Hammer
Made byProcter & GambleHenkelProcter & GambleChurch & Dwight
Price tierPremiumPremiumMid-rangeBudget
Known forStain removalStain removalStrong scentLow cost per load
Pods availableYesYes (Discs)Yes (Flings)Yes

Price tiers are typical shelf positioning; actual cost per load depends on bottle size and sales. Compare the per-load or per-ounce price on the shelf tag.

Persil vs. Tide

This is the closest match-up. Both brands put their strongest stain-fighting formulas at the top of their range, and in independent tests such as Consumer Reports' detergent ratings, premium formulas from both usually land near the top. Persil's scent is lighter and cleaner; Tide Original has the familiar "Tide smell". In practice, buy whichever costs less per load and whose scent you prefer.

Tide vs. Gain

Same company, different jobs. Tide is the cleaning-first brand. Gain is built around fragrance, and it pairs with Gain dryer sheets, softener and Fireworks scent beads if you want everything to smell the same. Gain is usually cheaper per load. For heavily stained work or kids' clothes, Tide; for everyday loads where scent matters to you, Gain.

Arm & Hammer vs. Tide

Arm & Hammer costs a fraction of Tide per load and is fine for lightly worn clothes, towels and sheets. Its weak spot is tough stains. A good budget routine: Arm & Hammer for most loads, plus a stain spray or oxygen booster on the stains that need it.

The bottles we would buy

  • Best all-round cleanerTide Original Liquid Detergent 64 loadsTide Original, 64 loads. Reliable on a wide range of stains, HE-safe, and sold everywhere.Check price on AmazonOur review
  • Premium alternativePersil AdvancedClean Liquid DetergentPersil AdvancedClean. Tide-level cleaning with a lighter scent; worth it when it costs the same or less per load.Check price on AmazonOur review
  • Best scentGain Original Liquid Laundry Detergent 134 loadsGain Original, 134 loads. Strong, long-lasting fragrance at a lower price per load than Tide.Check price on AmazonOur review
  • Best budgetArm & Hammer Clean Burst Liquid 170 loadsArm & Hammer Clean Burst, 170 loads. The lowest cost per load of the four for everyday laundry.Check price on AmazonOur review

Frequently asked questions

Is Persil better than Tide?

They are close. Both are premium detergents whose top formulas regularly score near the top of independent stain-removal tests, and both cost more per load than budget brands. Pick by scent, price per load where you shop, and which one is on sale; for most loads you will not see a difference.

Is Tide better than Gain?

Tide and Gain are both made by Procter & Gamble. Tide is positioned as the stronger cleaner and costs more; Gain is positioned around scent and value. If heavy stains are your main problem, Tide. If you want strong fragrance and a lower price, Gain.

Is Arm & Hammer detergent as good as Tide?

Arm & Hammer is a budget detergent and usually costs much less per load. For lightly soiled everyday clothes it does the job; for heavy stains, a premium detergent or a pre-treatment such as OxiClean or a stain spray helps more.

Who makes Persil, Tide, Gain and Arm & Hammer?

Tide and Gain are Procter & Gamble brands. Persil (in the US) is made by Henkel. Arm & Hammer is made by Church & Dwight.

Which detergent is best for a laundromat?

Any HE-labeled detergent works in laundromat front-loaders. Pods are the easiest to carry; a large bottle is cheaper per load if you can store it in your car or cart.

Related pages